top of page

MEET THE TEAM

We're a small office on purpose. When you call, one of us answers. When you check in on Saturday, one of us hands you the keys.

 

And when something comes up mid-week, you're talking to the people who know the house and know you. Here's who we are

Olivia profile pic

Olivia grew up in Westchester, New York, went to American University in Washington, DC, and moved to the beach in 2020. Before JFK, she ran day-to-day operations for a 66,000 square foot commercial property, looking after more than 150 tenants, the vendors who kept the building running, and every small problem in between. She's the one who will know which cleaner handles your house and which week you always book.

When she's not in the office, Olivia is in her garden, in the kitchen, or at Pilates and the gym.

CO-OWNER

OLIVIA BAILEY

Joel profile pic

CO-OWNER 

JOEL BAILEY

Licensed Delaware Real Estate Salesperson

Joel grew up in Princess Anne, Maryland, about an hour from Fenwick. He has been in mortgage lending since 2016, with more than 600 closings behind him. He knows what a house is worth and what it means to the family that owns it, and he handles our homeowner relationships with that in mind.

Joel spends his free time on the water fishing and at the billiards table. Ask him about tuna only if you have some time.

golden retriever

PAWFFICE MANAGER

HUDSON

Hudson is a golden retriever and the newest member of the staff. He greets every guest, reviews all feedback personally, and has never once taken a phone message. He holds no qualifications of any kind. He is very good with kids.

BLP.Kleinstuber-40.png

Rooted in Community

WHY WE LOVE
WHAT WE DO

For most of the families we work with, a week in Fenwick isn't just a booking. It's the week the rest of the year is planned around. Some have been coming for more than thirty years, and the kids who grew up on this beach are now bringing their own grandchildren. We get to be a small part of that, and we don't take it lightly.

 

We both came to this work because we like people and we like connecting them. Fenwick made it easy to stay. It's a town where neighbors look out for one another, and we wanted to build something here that gives back to it.

 

So our job is simple: have the house ready, handle the details, and be easy to reach. That way the week itself is the part you remember.

HISTORY OF KLEINSTUBER

JFK logo

John F. Kleinstuber & Associates was founded in 1977 by Jack Kleinstuber, back when Fenwick Island was a quiet stretch of coast known mostly to the families who summered here year after year. Jack built the business the only way that works in a small town: one handshake at a time. He learned which houses caught the best evening light, which families needed the extra bedroom now that the grandchildren were coming, and which week in July a family had claimed as their own for a decade running.

 

His children, John and Nancy, took over and ran the company together for the better part of forty years. Just the two of them, no staff, no call center. They kept the ledgers, answered the phone, met the vendors, and walked the properties themselves. While the rest of the industry moved to apps and instant booking, they stayed personal on purpose. It's why so many of our owners and renters are third generation: their parents and grandparents booked with Jack, and they still book with us.

 

In 2026, the business passed to Joel and Olivia Bailey. Our job is to keep what made this company what it is (full-week stays, real relationships, a phone answered by someone who knows your name) while making the parts that should have been easier all along a little easier.

 

Nearly fifty years, one town, and a client list that reads like a family tree. We intend to keep it that way.

BLP.Kleinstuber-56.png
Textured Sand Surface

A small town with a long memory

FENWICK ISLAND, DELAWARE

Fenwick Island takes its name from Thomas Fenwick, who was given the land in 1692, back when it was a true island cut off by inlets from the bay. Local legend says his son-in-law, William Fassett, first arrived here by swimming ashore after being thrown overboard from a pirate ship. We can't promise that one is true, but it's been told around here for a long time.

 

Fenwick is also where Delaware begins. In 1751, colonial surveyors set a stone at the edge of the beach to mark the line between Maryland and the land that would become Delaware. It still stands today, carved with Lord Baltimore's coat of arms on one side and William Penn's on the other. That stone is older than the country.

A century later, ships kept wrecking on the shoals just offshore, so the government built the Fenwick Island Lighthouse. It was first lit in the summer of 1859 and guided ships for nearly 120 years. When it went dark in 1978, the community fought to save it, and it was relit a few years later. It's the last lighthouse still standing right on the Atlantic coast of Delaware or Maryland, and you can see it from Coastal Highway. For most of its history, Fenwick was a place few people reached. The first bridge came around 1880, and the early cottages had no electricity or running water. After World War II, families started finding their way here, and the opening of the Bay Bridge in 1952 brought many more. That's when Fenwick made the decision that still defines it. As high-rises crept north from Ocean City, residents voted to incorporate in 1953 so they could keep the town quiet, residential, and built for families. It worked. Fenwick is still the kind of place where you bike to the beach, know your neighbors, and come back to the same house every summer. That's the town Jack Kleinstuber started renting homes in back in 1977, and the town we're proud to call home today.

seashell pic
JFK white transparen

John F. Kleinstuber & Associates

Licensed real estate brokerage in Delaware 

Broker of record: John F. Kleinstuber

Delaware Accommodations Intermediary License #2026953619

CONTACT US

911 Coastal Highway,

Fenwick Island, DE 19944

Office: (302) 539-4081

contact@fenwickisland.com

Equal-Housing-Opportunity-Logo_edited.pn

We are committed to equal housing opportunity and comply with federal and Delaware fair housing laws.

  • Facebook
bottom of page